Introduction
This question tests two important grammar skills commonly seen in PSLE English:
- Recognising uncountable nouns (e.g., luggage)
- Choosing the correct tense to show an ongoing situation
The teacher’s explanation highlights that the luggage is still missing, so the tense must reflect a situation that began in the past and continues into the present.
The Question
The hotel guests are facing much inconvenience as all their luggage ______ missing up to now.
Options:
- are
- is
- has been ✔
- have been
Correct Answer: (3) has been
Step-by-Step Explanation (Following Teacher’s Working)
Step 1 — Identify the true subject
The phrase in the blank refers to:
luggage → an uncountable noun → always singular
So options using are or have been can be removed immediately.
Step 2 — Consider the meaning of “up to now”
The phrase “up to now” signals:
- Something started earlier
- Still happening in the present
- Effects are ongoing
This requires present perfect tense.
Present perfect (singular) = has been
Step 3 — Combine grammar + meaning
✔ Singular subject → has
✔ Ongoing missing luggage → has been missing up to now
Therefore:
Correct: all their luggage has been missing up to now
Key Concepts
| Concept | Explanation |
| Uncountable nouns | “Luggage” has no plural form; always treated as singular |
| Present perfect tense | Used for actions that started in the past and continue to the present |
| Context clues | Phrases like “up to now”, “so far”, “recently” indicate present perfect |
| Singular vs plural verbs | Singular → has, plural → have |
Tips for Students
✔ Identify whether the noun is countable or uncountable before choosing a verb.
✔ Words like luggage, furniture, equipment, homework are always singular.
✔ Look for time markers like up to now, so far, since → these signal present perfect.
✔ Eliminate options that don’t match both tense and subject number.
For Parents
This PSLE English skill goes beyond memorising rules. Students must understand:
- grammatical number (singular vs plural)
- time reference (tenses must match meaning)
Mastering this ensures better accuracy in Grammar MCQ, Editing, and even Composition writing.