PSLE English – Inconvenience & Correct Tense Usage (Missing Luggage Question)

Source: PSLE English Grammar – Inconvenience Tense Question

Introduction

This question tests two important grammar skills commonly seen in PSLE English:

  1. Recognising uncountable nouns (e.g., luggage) 
  2. Choosing the correct tense to show an ongoing situation 

The teacher’s explanation highlights that the luggage is still missing, so the tense must reflect a situation that began in the past and continues into the present.

 

The Question

The hotel guests are facing much inconvenience as all their luggage ______ missing up to now.

Options:

  1. are 
  2. is 
  3. has been ✔ 
  4. have been 

Correct Answer: (3) has been

 

Step-by-Step Explanation (Following Teacher’s Working)

Step 1 — Identify the true subject

The phrase in the blank refers to:

luggage → an uncountable noun → always singular

So options using are or have been can be removed immediately.

Step 2 — Consider the meaning of “up to now”

The phrase “up to now” signals:

  • Something started earlier 
  • Still happening in the present 
  • Effects are ongoing 

This requires present perfect tense.

Present perfect (singular) = has been

Step 3 — Combine grammar + meaning

✔ Singular subject → has
✔ Ongoing missing luggage → has been missing up to now

Therefore:

Correct: all their luggage has been missing up to now

 

Key Concepts

ConceptExplanation
Uncountable nouns“Luggage” has no plural form; always treated as singular
Present perfect tenseUsed for actions that started in the past and continue to the present
Context cluesPhrases like “up to now”, “so far”, “recently” indicate present perfect
Singular vs plural verbsSingular → has, plural → have

 

Tips for Students

✔ Identify whether the noun is countable or uncountable before choosing a verb.
✔ Words like luggage, furniture, equipment, homework are always singular.
✔ Look for time markers like up to now, so far, since → these signal present perfect.
✔ Eliminate options that don’t match both tense and subject number.

 

For Parents

This PSLE English skill goes beyond memorising rules. Students must understand:

  • grammatical number (singular vs plural) 
  • time reference (tenses must match meaning) 

Mastering this ensures better accuracy in Grammar MCQ, Editing, and even Composition writing.

 

Want your child to master PSLE grammar with confidence?
Book a Free Trial Lesson at MasterEnglish today!
Frequently Asked Questions

Because luggage is uncountable, so plural verbs cannot be used.

It ignores the time phrase “up to now”, which requires present perfect tense.

It shows a continuous state from past → present.